It's not a secret that men love to openly stare at women's boobs and butts, however women are usually (not always) a bit more subtle about checking guys out. But women definitely do like to ogle hunky guys, make no mistake about it. Women on reddit were asked on this AskReddit thread to share the first thing they check out when they spot a new guy. Here's what they said.
1. Don't worry, lexiethesasquatch. We're all a little bit creepy deep down inside.
Your forearms, especially if you're carrying something like a heavy box but don't just flex randomly like those guys on Instagram. That is such a turn off for me.
I also like your backs for some reason which is kind of perfect anyway because then you can't see me checking you out, especially on the beach when guys are topless.
I feel like a creep now. Thank you.
2. chicklet2011's very specific response shows that she's a girl who knows what she wants. I respect that.
Traps, shoulder width, biceps, forearms, facial hair/jawline, height, and butt. I also consider body fat distribution. I don't mind a guy who is on the high end of average, but I prefer even distribution, not all in the gut/breast.
Oh. Also chest hair :-)
Edit: teeth. Also doesn't have to be perfect, most combinations of missing/off-white/crooked are permissible if you pick 2 of the 3.