Things got a little personal when Joe Jonas stopped by Bravo's Watch What Happens Live last night. During the show's "Plead The Fifth" segment, Andy Cohen challenged Joe to a wholesome game of Shag/Marry/Kill. The three options? Gigi Hadid, Demi Lovato, and Taylor Swift—all Joe's ex-girlfriends.

Joe had the option to plead the fifth and not answer the question, but lucky for us, he accepted the challenge. Here's the video: