Advertising

I don't know if you checked out the cookie aisle at the supermarket lately, but Oreo keeps churning out crazier and crazier variants on the classic cookie-and-creme formula. And this latest product seems too ridiculous to be true.

OK, OK, nobody really thinks "All Stuf" Oreos are real. But now that April Fools' Day and Photoshop have opened up the possibility, we're wondering if they should be. Isn't the creme everybody's favorite part anyway?

Advertising
Advertising

Not everyone was on board, though. In fact, Oreo creme is shockingly divisive.

Advertising
Advertising

Does any other cookie inspire this much debate? You never see people go in like this about Milanos. Anyway, probably the only thing keeping the Oreo inventors from doing this for real is the lack of structural integrity in an all-creme cookie, and they'd probably all stick together in the sleeve. Though for the true creme-heads among us, that could be a selling point.